Monday, 6 October 2025

 Another play on Nati Binodini



.             Nati Binodini,the name is pronounced today with a lot of respect, as a Prima Dona she was called in her hey days in end 18th and 19th century Bengal. This is because the word nati has changed its connotation. Today it means actress or the more gender neutral actor, a matter of glamour. It was not so in those times. It had a connotation of immorality, of an association with men of questionable character, and as is the norm in all ages, every such reference is suggestive of the opinion that anyone had the liberty of sleeping with her.


                        She was a great actor, this audiences would admit openly, People would flock to see her play roles of historical to religious to mythological characters, which come to life with songs and dances, that was, in today's parlance paisa wasool entertainment. But she mistook their adulation for recognition. She asked for too much. She asked for a stage dedicated to theatre built and named after her as B theatre. A theatre named after a harlot? You can't expect respectable people to go and watch theatre there! A bigger shock awaited her. Her colleagues in theatre including her mentor, Girish babu, forced her to become a kept for Gurmukh Ray, her then suitor, because in return, Ray would build a theatre named after her for them. When faced by rejection from the audience they turned on her once again to accept the name Star Theatre because she was a star, It was in her name only. they said.


            Even after all this, such was her love for stage that she continued to perform at the very theatre that she had dreamt would be named after her and would be dedicated to theatre and theatre only, As her health deteriorated, she was gradually eased out of her roles and then from theatre itself.


            In 1935, the building housing Star Theatre, caught fire and was completely gutted. It was restored in 2001 with the same name, structure and facade. But by then, Commercial theatre had itself lost out to Cinema and gradually most theatres had closed down. Star met the same fate. It has recently been named after Binodini as B Theatre, but sadly plays movies. The dreams of Noti Binodini for Binodini Theatre to be dedicated to the stage remain unfulfilled. Theatre workers are striving to make it come true.


                    To tell this story, the play has listed almost all the important events in Binodini's life, already known to most of us, serially as in a history book. This has slowed down the play, reduced the role of the protagonist, and made it overly lengthy. The curtain rose at 6.40pm that evening and finally came down at around 9.20 pm. After the curtain call before which the audience normally do not leave ,it was9.40pm, It could be cut down by half an hour at the least. The viewers, who are usually held spellbound by Sudipta Chakrabory when on stage, took time to clear their throats and having a look at their mobile screens, when the actions and dialogues become very predictable. In one scene, when Kumar Bahadur, her then paramour, leaves her on a boat, with a not very convincing promise to return in a few days, he collides with a piece o furniture. A lady seated near me predicts what we all thought ; he will not return, And true to her forecast, Binodini's mother steps on to the stage to tell her and the audience that Kumar Bahadur had got married to his family's chosen one at his village. What follows is Binodini's loud laments amid the equally loud audio-visuals of Kumar Bahadur getting married. Later, when Binodini is in distress, on a bed (God knows why a number of melodramatic sequences take place on that bed just because she had fallen ill on it sometime back. but that's another story) Kumar Bahadur walks through the half dark stage. The lady in the audience predicts once again, Binodini is having a dream. And Binodini;s mother once again comes on stage to confirm that Kumar Bahadur had died the night before. The curtain fell, marking half-time a little before that, after Binodini's public lament over her paramour's marriage. I think she was made of sterner staff.


                    I take this brief break to convey something different. During my previous era of enjoying plays, some ages back, really there were no mobile phones. Such a time actually existed. Now there is another demon called a smart phone which is never switched off by its owner. Only the ring volume is reduced to low by most of the audience. But the phone is so smart that, like a naughty child, it knows a thousand tricks to demand attention through whispered sighs and the sound of falling teardrops. And like a guilty mother, afraid of having hurt her ignored child you open the phone to face a brightly lit screen and immediately try to find out how many heavens have fallen down from the sky in these last few minutes. In a movie hall you look up at a brightly lt screen and hear thousands of watts of Dolby Atmos sound that can physically shake you if you are seated near a speaker. But a drama stage is mostly at your normal eye level, and below it if you are on the balcony. It is also not very bright and often dimly lit according to the scene. In a darkened and silent hall, even the sound of a mobile's vibration is quite irritating, let alone repeated bursts of light even from 10 rows in front of you or below. I know you cannot control your spontaneous outbursts, but you can definitely control your phone. I am sure, your worst fears wont come true during the two or two and half hours max if you  switch off your phones for that period. A play asks just that much time from you, It is a live show, one for which you and your co audience have paid a sizeable amount of money and which you most probably would never watch a second time. Please tell your phone that you are the boss. I have actually seen a person discussing targets of a pan India sales campaign during the interval of a hindi play and leave midway after a couple of vibrations on his phone. HE was a boss, I don't know to how many sales persons but definitely to his phone.


                    I have seen young members of a well known theatre group,, made famous by their now deceased lead actress and director, some of whom even come on stage a few minutes later doublecheck politely before you enter the hall, that you have actually switched off your phone. There the audience of just about 60 + is almost on the stage in 8 rows ,each row a foot higher than the one in front. There are no seat numbers, only three classes. They lead you, if necessary ,as it was in my case, by holding your hand, to an empty seat in a darkened hall holding those black light torches. I was seated in the very front row, probably because of my age, beside a famous newspaper columnist, whom they called "didi". Music from the theatre was already playing under dim lights and Theatre itself was so imposing in the space that I could think of nothing but the sacred stage literally touching my naked feet. I was so nervous that a ring from my phone would be guillotines for me that I checked three times surreptitiously that my phone could not emit a sound under any circumstances. Now as I write I suddenly develop Goosebumps remembering that my phone sounds alarms even when switched off and I had alarms set in the evening for medicines. But I am relieved after a few seconds recalling that I had shut down the sound and vibration as well. Yes, another thing, you have to take off your shoes and place them on a shoe rack as you enter their premises. All actors and members were bare feet. You get an idea of the capacity of the hall from the size of the sturdy and clean shoe rack, And every inch of the property is tidy and neat and cared for. It is their own stage, named after their deceased mentor and they treat her memory with respect.


                You might wonder why I have written so many lines not connected with the play under discussion. Because there was not much to write about. A comparison with a concurrent play about another greatly wronged famous female artist would be tempting, but I refrain in honour of the lead actress of Nati Binodini, who has illuminated our stages and later movies for so long. I long for what could have been history.



                    One last thing. To draw a parallel to Binodini's deceiving band of suitors and co-actors, lines from Sunil Gangopadhyay's poem Keu Katha Rakhena, have been put on Binodini's lips.  Firstly, the poem is too famous to be set more than two centuries back. Secondly it entirely depicts a sense of loss of longings for things and good times that others showed off before their hungry eyes, promises to experience wonders that were not kept, entirely from a male perspective. Binodini's losses are that of trust, that of insincere love and a never to materialise dream for a home and a caring husband. All she got were people who used her to attain their goals or satisfy their lust and their egos. And she always laments. Not for once I saw her hold a commanding stance as appearing in the poster above.


            A request for the Kalamandir management. Ladies, mainly senior,  constituted majority of the audience. There is no Ladies Rest Room on the first and second floors where the hall and the balcony sets are located. Please provide them this basic facility at the earliest.



 

Recently I watched a number of films on OTT Out of them, some were very different. Their plots were not ordinary, Here I would like to discuss them briefly. Firstly I liked them very much.



But before that, the film we watched long back in our College days, in the seventies. Society was not so open in those times. The social permissiveness shown in this Hollywood film that captured their societies in 1942 during the war, among adolescents was envied by us as young adults with silky thin moustaches and daily clean shaven looks, Beards among our clan were only for the intellectuals who wore round glasses and carried side bags, If you have not already guessed from the year already, yes, it was Summer of 42 staring a stunning Jeniffer O'Neal with a bunch of school going kids boys and girls in their teens. Nowadays these films have a generic name, Growing up stories, Well, we actually grew up watching these films. It was all told from a boy's point of view. I still vividly remember the ending. I felt as sad as the boy. In the final scene, Hermie, suddenly approaching manhood, is seen looking at Dorothy's old house and the ocean from a distance before he turns to join his friends. To bittersweet music, the adult Raucher sadly recounts that he never saw Dorothy again or learned what became of her. It remains a part of our lives. If you have watched the film and remembered it and for those who have not, I leave a link to the sory of the film. See if it makes you watch the film, again maybe,



Now all this came back to me when I watched the film Girls will be Girls, on OTT recently, It is the same story in today's India in a small hill town with a prestigious co-ed school but told from a girl's point of view, The girl is as interested and as naïve as those boys in the West ,80 years ago. The boy, a little older and with exposure to foreign lands and people, is not so naïve and always interested. He has also learned to manipulate people He is a little shrewd, I would say, nothing evil. And the other boys are really jelous and angry at their failure to win the maiden's attention and at her squealing about their pranks or misadventures as you choose to call them. Some girls are drawn to the so called bad boys with a sense of daring and like always, teachers caution the girls and punish the boys, as we would say. Parents, however, continue to poke their noses into everything from lengths of dresses to the very important BOARD EXAMS as always. Now in old age, I remember our times and smile. The boys and girls today have caught up with those of the '42 , maybe quite some time back. I never knew. Watch the film to know for yourself,


The others follow one by one,

Thursday, 13 March 2025

                                               DABBA CARTEL

                                                 ON NETFLIX


Top of Form

 


I must confess, I started watching  Dabba Cartel with a mix of curiosity and trepidation. The world of Mumbai's dabbawalas and tiffin delivery service are used to deliver drugs. If you have watched Breaking Bad, you will recognise the drug. Here it is called MDM and later in its green coloured version Mithai. (Remember the blue coloured Meth from Breaking Bad?)I found myself drawn into the complex web of characters and storylines. The show's leading old lady, mother in law Shiela(played with grand aplomb by an aged and sharp Shabana Azmi in a refreshingly different avtar), who has retired from a treacherous background, is forced to  reveal her true colours to protect her innocent daughter in law from her over ambitious son and the mess she gets into to earn lots of money to fund his dreams.


 

·         From unscrupulous pharma companies to blackmailing and terrorising drug peddlers and dealers, the show sheds light on the dark underbelly of Mumbai's prosperous exterior.

It is essentially a show of the 6 ladies tied down in a web of ego, greed power, ambition, duty and survival.

·          

·         It also highlights the ambitons of the kamwali bai, Mala,(played by an effervescent Nimisha Sajayan) taking on the black mailers and a dark world to meet her dreams of a high flying life for herself and her daughter. When her school going daughter says that the TV she bought was too big for their small room, she says she will take a bigger house.


·         Mother in law Sheila is street smart and fiercely protective. When a consignment of drugs are accidentally destroyed and the drug dealer demands that they sell more drugs to recover his loss, she admits there is no way out. It had to be done. At another point she admits to her daughter in law, adamant to stick to routine life, that she was not born for the chula chowka stuff.

The daughter in law is Raji Jagtap (played with sweet innocence by  Shalini Pandey) . At a crisis point when the consignment has to be stolen from her husband to save themselves, she defies her mother in law saying she would not steal.

The house broker Shahida (played a bubbly Anjali Anand)is your everyday greedy agent who has an attraction for the lady Police Officer Preeti looking for a big case to get her promotion(played with the daring eagerness of an young lady in search of her dreams by Sai Tamhankar).

Varuna (played by a dignified and sad looking Jyotika ) is the ignored and side tracked wife of Shankar Dasgupta(played by a sauve Jisshu Sengupta), the manipulative local boss of the unscrupulous pharma company.

The investigation into the pharma company which causes all this trouble is doggedly pursued even in the threat of suspension by Arun Pathak, a close to retirement Drug Safety Officer (played with a mostly poker face by  Gajraj Rao ) who has some  interesting interactions with the  young and daring lady police officer.


 

If I have any quibbles, it's that the pacing can be a bit uneven at times. Some episodes feel a bit slow, while others are breakneck in their intensity. But overall, "Dabba Cartel" is a gripping and intense watch that's hard to look away from.

 

In short, if you're a fan of gritty, intense drama, "Dabba Cartel" is a must-watch. Just be prepared for a wild ride.                                            .IMDB rating 7.1


Sunday, 30 June 2024



    I reopen my blog after a rather long break. I start with my take on the OTT channels that are demanding our eyeballs  from all across the net.  I have named it WHATSONOTT after a popular app.


We start with a recent addition. The film Maidaan. Featuring one of the most visible faces on screen. Ajay Devgn. The story is from the history of Indian football from which we continue to learn nothing.  And casually forget the inspiring men who took India to the top of Asian Football where we could never reach again to this day.  In the face of staunch opposition. From some of us Indians only. We remember headlines from a foggy memory to say “yeah yeah. The 60s Asian Games Gold. But that was so long ago. Since then we are going down only.” But then we forget our country's history too! Big results are the outcome of long, hard efforts and a planned pursuit of the goal.

 

 

       The 1962 gold medal was made possible by the vision of one man and his dogged pursuit for more than a decade.  His toil, leadership, talent spotting ability and strategy building. And courage. Facing back biting, neglect insult and enmity that comes with it. He was Syed Abdul Rahim. Maidaan is his story.

 

I was in school in the 60s. Football dominated the Sports pages of vernacular dailies and radio commentaries. It was mostly local. Cricket came in the winter months only in its Test avatar. And when there was an international cricket tour of India. Heroes like Jaiseema, Patoudi, Farokh Engineer and Salim Durani were reserved for those times. The occasional Indian cricket wins were not sufficient to garner yearlong interest. 


    Quarter page photographs of Chuni Goswami, P K Banerjee, Balaram and Peter Thongoraj  in action, Bengali commentary of Ajayda and Kamalda telling us about a  thikana lekha pass (an accurate pass) just rocked. Brazil, Latin American football was read about. You read about Pele, Eusebio and Lev Yasin the Russian Goalkeeper. More enthusiastic classmates would speak of Czech and Hungarian football, Cruyiff and Puskas. But East Bengal Mohun Bagan and Mohammedan Sporting dominated our world of sports.

 

Chuni Goswami’s flamboyance was as famous as his swerving free kicks. We heard and saw Beckham bending them much much later. And this era is brought to life in Maidaan. The Raj Era buildings, trams trundling down the green maidan, the laid back life, children playing football in the mud, big black umbrellas and our childhood heroes winning on celluloid.

 

Football matches were brought alive by shots and sounds of a football landing in the mud so you would feel the splash, tearing the net with the power of a kick, bare feet with only anklets  struggling to stop foreign boots.

 

The ferocity of the matches confronts us. Even if we know the outcome, the grit of the players comes through. Chuni’s free kick swerving past the wall into the South Korean goal makes us yearn for an action replay from all different angles. And the one man behind it all, who had to convince everyone, even the Prime Minister, to send a football team to Jakarta with an assurance of a gold medal. He knew it was his swan song.

 

So it was for Indian football too!

 

Maidaan is playing on Prime video. Watch it. I felt the National flag going up and the national anthem playing.


 


Saturday, 15 June 2024

Ek Chabi Anyo Gaan





Somehow I was always more fascinated by sound  rather than pictures. One reason maybe that a typical sound registered its association instantly and accurately each time. A picture did that too but it seemed slower and less accurate. With the gradual improvement in sound technology, the waves became live, each individual sound  registered separately. Also, in the home entertainment sector, all  the latest developments in sound technology came at an affordable cost, while the upscale home video came at a prohibitive high investment . True, the thumping bass ruled for a while, but sanity returned to delight listeners with true sound that immersed the listener.


Most of the songs in modern movies have become mood enhancers rather than story tellers. And can  add another dimension to  nicely crafted sequences from another movie. To me it adds visual pleasure to the song.

I have remixed a few songs and film sequences and found immense pleasure, both in matching them and viewing them. 

Saturday, 26 September 2015

The Pakistani TV serial MAAT








The picture above is of Rinki Bhattacharya (Roy). She is the daughter of the famed Film Director, Bimal Roy and wife of another serious filmmaker Basu Bhattacharya. Some years back, she used to appear regularly on TV, mainly DD Kolkata/ National, to participate in discussions on  films and of course the creations of her father and hand her husband..

She is an ardent advocate of good cinema, mainstream or otherwise. And now, when excellent creations for the small screen have overtaken movies, their big brother, both in terms of quality and quantity, she has accepted them with open arms.
I came across her review of Zindagi Channel on Rediff and got hooked.

Some excerpts from her writings:
September 14, 2014 16:01 IST
The television shows aired on Zindagi channel are intelligently scripted and elegantly mounted, writes Rinki Roy Bhattacharya.
A chance remark about Zindagi channel’s women-sensitive content made me curious enough to switch it on. The channel airs Pakistani syndicated shows in India.
What I discovered were intense human dramas of love, betrayal, deception and exploitation, with a special emphasis on man-woman relationships.
Few other channels portray complex human drama with such undivided attention, especially in a society conflicted by political ideology.
The stories aired on Zindagi are intelligently scripted and elegantly mounted.
Pakistani cultural values are at play in these stories and yet they have a universal appeal. Human emotions are so alike in most cultures, that these stories could be staged anywhere from Lahore to London.
I stumbled on the channel at the precise point when the poignant Maat had reached its suspenseful second half, and have been a regular watcher since.
Zindagi’s realistic portrayal of Pakistani society does not shy away from showing its ugly underbelly.
The people we see are real, their aspirations and frustrations very convincing. This is one of its greatest triumphs.
Kahi Unkahi, for example, is preoccupied with a class-ridden society where the working class is treated with contempt bordering on inhumanity.
Zindagi Gulzar Hai is about campus life, student politics and the youthful romance between two students, who hate each other and then prove that opposites attract.
In Kaash Main Teri Beti Na Hoti, a nobleman hires the womb of a pretty but poor girl with the intention of discarding her once the progeny is born. It is a shrill melodrama, rather like our familiar telly dramas.
Zindagi has successfully seduced urban Indian viewers, especially those who can recall Dhoop Kinare and Tanhaiya from 30 years ago.
Indian viewers fell head over heels in love with the bubbly intern, Dr Zoya in Dhoop Kinare. Viewers held their breath as her romance with Dr Ansari progressed quietly in its old fashioned style through stolen glances and unspoken words. A dear friend recently confessed he is waiting to find a Dr Zoya! The compelling power of this medium cannot be ignored.The Zindagi channel also shows some fine telly films, such as Behadd, a deceptively simple love story.
The film explores a relevant universal concern -- the guilt single parents suffer in asserting their individual choice.
It revolves around an attractive widow, who is a working mother. Friends, including her boss, worry about the way she is raising her 15-year-old daughter Maha. If the mother is overprotective, the daughter is fiercely possessive.
The opening scene establishes Maha’s power over her mother. It is obvious that Maha resents sharing her mother. Maternal fragility and the overwhelming emotional demands of selfish adolescents are familiar issues in any contemporary urban society.
The Behadd subtext gently probes how younger men find older, mature women less challenging and thus extremely desirable.
The Zindagi channel also shows some fine telly films, such as Behadd, a deceptively simple love story.
The film explores a relevant universal concern -- the guilt single parents suffer in asserting their individual choice.
It revolves around an attractive widow, who is a working mother. Friends, including her boss, worry about the way she is raising her 15-year-old daughter Maha. If the mother is overprotective, the daughter is fiercely possessive.
The opening scene establishes Maha’s power over her mother. It is obvious that Maha resents sharing her mother. Maternal fragility and the overwhelming emotional demands of selfish adolescents are familiar issues in any contemporary urban society.
The Behadd subtext gently probes how younger men find older, mature women less challenging and thus extremely desirable.”
=============================================


.

And then I watched Maat. Saba Qamar, picture above, is the greedy and beautiful younger sister Saman. She wants the entire world for herself and is bold enough to lie, cheat or steal her way through life.

Eman( Aamina Sheikh) is the elder, homely, protective, caring. She ends up slaving for Saman. In return, Saman  hijacks her  savings for her wedding, her dresses and even the man she is engaged to, Faisal. And when she finds a richer alternative in Azhar, she switches sides with her sweet talk.







Adnan Siddiqui portrays Faisal perfectly as the simple man helplessly in love with a scheming woman. He tries in vain to please her and ends up being blamed by everyone. 



 










What leaves you always craving for the next episode is the swift movement of the plot and the intense acting. One side glance from Saba Qamar at Eman’s wedding dress reveals Saman’s greed. 




 Adnan Siddiqui’s  school boyish smile as he opens the door of his new car for Saman is a picture of Faisal’s  helpless surrender. Aamina Sheikh’s  moist eyes, as Saman leaves Faizal for Azhar and blames Eman ,  pleads to deaf ears for Eman’s innocence.